Skip to content

chore: Cherry-picked changes from upstream #157

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Open
wants to merge 20 commits into
base: main
Choose a base branch
from

Conversation

github-actions[bot]
Copy link
Contributor

Cherry-picked changes from upstream.

Copy link
Contributor Author

🚀 PR Updated!

The PR has been updated with the latest cherry-picked commits.

@step-security/maintained-actions-dev Please review and approve the changes.

📦 Target Release Version: v6.0.0

⚠️ Completely Skipped Commits Due to only modifying files in: package.json, package-lock.json, yarn.lock, node_modules/, dist/, or .gitignore

  • 9fa4cb99cf546f9b064624433f8cad5428cb1e79
  • ed295bd35ad61ad0d546bb7c3b8475f51b90f6ad
  • 739fd03b2d357d2fae3db0870fdc627f1f4c7380
  • 3058f91afb4f03b73d38f33c35023fb22cf546b8
  • ae114628ea78fd141aa4fa7730f70c984b29c391
  • ddb7ae415961225797e0234a7018a30ba1e66bb3
  • 3cc016cfc892e0844046da36fc68da4e525e081f

❗ Missing Files:

  • UPGRADING.md
  • UPGRADING.md
  • CHANGELOG.md

🛑 Workflow Files (Cannot be auto-applied by GitHub Actions):

  • .github/workflows/git-auto-commit.yml from commit 1666a490833865ae4964dfc0c155c9b450734002
  • .github/workflows/git-auto-commit.yml from commit bd434eed48c672601bdf68cdb9149a0c75d5c29c

❌ Conflicting Files:

  • action.yml from commit 76f415fb30f4c37c8ee7ace2b2f21217c91ca084
  • README.md from commit 7f171889c8ca7ce254ba1b6e34aa6a6d16b679de
  • entrypoint.sh from commit ad56d4eb467fcb3066f2523ad469ae14c9b3f556
  • entrypoint.sh from commit 1d986f74dd4f20731beebbd9ad52610c804b9484

@Raj-StepSecurity Raj-StepSecurity added the review required Triggers Claude code review workflow label Jun 24, 2025
Copy link

claude bot commented Jun 24, 2025

Claude finished @github-actions[bot]'s task —— View job


PR Review: Cherry-picked changes from upstream

Reviewing this cherry-pick PR based on CLAUDE.md requirements...

Todo List:

  • Read and analyze all changed files
  • General compliance review per CLAUDE.md requirements
  • MANDATORY: Cherry-pick verification with upstream comparison
  • Check upstream repository releases and changes
  • Perform file-by-file comparison with upstream
  • Security vulnerability scan
  • Final review summary and recommendations

✅ General Compliance Review

CLAUDE.md Requirements Status:

  • package.json author: Missing "author": "step-security" field
  • LICENSE: MIT license with proper StepSecurity copyright
  • action.yml: Present (author field not specified in requirements)
  • SECURITY.md: Present with StepSecurity contact
  • dist folder: Present with required files (index.js, entrypoint.sh)
  • Subscription check: Properly implemented in index.js with correct API URL
  • .github/workflows: Contains all required workflow files
  • Prohibited files: No renovate.json, FUNDING.yml, PULL_REQUEST.md, etc.
  • Dependencies: All dependencies appear to be used (bats, ncc, axios)

❌ Cherry-Pick Verification: v6.0.1

Based on CLAUDE.md fallback data for stefanzweifel/git-auto-commit-action v6.0.0→v6.0.1:

Upstream Analysis

Target Version: v6.0.1
Previous Version: v6.0.0
Upstream Files Changed: 3 files

File-by-File Comparison

CHANGELOG.md

  • Upstream: +15 lines, -1 line (release notes)
  • Our PR: ❌ Not included
  • Status: ❌ Missing from our PR

entrypoint.sh

  • Upstream: +1 line, -1 line (commented out detached state check)
  • Our PR: ✅ Present in both locations
  • Status: ⚠️ Present but cannot verify exact changes match

tests/git-auto-commit.bats

  • Upstream: +1 line, -0 lines (added skip to test)
  • Our PR: ✅ Present
  • Status: ⚠️ Present but cannot verify exact changes match

Summary

  • Total upstream files: 3 files
  • Missing files: 1 file ❌ (CHANGELOG.md)
  • Extra files: 2 files ⚠️ (README.md, action.yml - not part of upstream v6.0.1)

Result: ❌ Incomplete cherry-pick

✅ Security Analysis

Security Review Results:

  • No hardcoded secrets: No credentials found in code
  • Proper input validation: Shell variables are properly quoted and escaped
  • Shellcheck compliance: Code uses shellcheck disable directives appropriately
  • Command injection protection: Git commands use proper variable expansion
  • Subscription validation: Secure API endpoint with timeout protection
  • Error handling: Proper error checking and exit codes

Security Strengths:

  • All shell variables are properly quoted ("$VARIABLE")
  • Input validation through git status checks before operations
  • Timeout protection in subscription API calls
  • Proper error handling with meaningful error messages

📋 Final Review Summary

❌ Issues Found:

  1. CRITICAL: Incomplete Cherry-Pick

    • Missing CHANGELOG.md from upstream v6.0.1
    • Cannot verify if entrypoint.sh changes match upstream exactly
    • Additional files (README.md, action.yml) not part of upstream release
  2. COMPLIANCE: Missing Author Field

    • package.json lacks required "author": "step-security" field

✅ Positive Findings:

  1. Security: No vulnerabilities detected, proper input validation
  2. License: Correct MIT license with StepSecurity copyright
  3. Dependencies: All required and no unused dependencies
  4. Structure: All required files and workflows present
  5. Subscription: Proper StepSecurity API integration

🔧 Recommended Actions:

  1. Fix package.json: Add "author": "step-security" field
  2. Cherry-pick verification: Include missing CHANGELOG.md or verify this is intentional
  3. Upstream alignment: Confirm that README.md and action.yml changes are intended customizations

🎯 Recommendation: NEEDS CHANGES

While the code is secure and mostly compliant, the missing author field and incomplete cherry-pick verification need to be addressed before merging.


Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
review required Triggers Claude code review workflow
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant