possible extensions for AddOpeningHours, AddWheelchairAccessBusiness, AddPlaceName

[matkoniecz]

list made with https://codeberg.org/matkoniecz/detect_missing_value_support_in_streetcomplete

I made initial review and listed some, added several to ignored in https://codeberg.org/matkoniecz/detect_missing_value_support_in_streetcomplete

I suspect that few more may be eligible for this quests - feel free to either point out clear cases in comments or open PR. Matching PRs adding entries to list of ignored in https://codeberg.org/matkoniecz/detect_missing_value_support_in_streetcomplete are also welcome, but just tested StreetComplete PR would be great.

See ed3acb0 or 4521024 commits that applied some of suggestions

following seems likely, not entirely sure whether they should be added or ignored (feel free to make PRs/commits if you see clear cases either way):

reviewed in #6402 (comment)

amenity = grave_yard AddPlaceName
amenity = grave_yard AddOpeningHours
amenity = grave_yard AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
leisure = ice_rink AddOpeningHours
leisure = indoor_play AddPlaceName
leisure = indoor_play AddOpeningHours
leisure = indoor_play AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = public_bath AddPlaceName
amenity = public_bath AddOpeningHours
amenity = public_bath AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

office = adoption_agency AddOpeningHours
office = adoption_agency AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
leisure = beach_resort AddPlaceName
leisure = beach_resort AddOpeningHours
leisure = beach_resort AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
leisure = bird_hide AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = gambling AddOpeningHours
amenity = toy_library AddPlaceName
amenity = toy_library AddOpeningHours
amenity = toy_library AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = swingerclub AddPlaceName
amenity = swingerclub AddOpeningHours
amenity = swingerclub AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = funeral_hall AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = crematorium AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = events_venue AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

Some new ones, with similar opinion:

healthcare = rehabilitation AddOpeningHours
office = charity AddOpeningHours
office = charity AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = union AddOpeningHours
office = union AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

expect those to be by appointment, so opening hours should be likely not asked here:

craft = blacksmith AddOpeningHours
craft = blacksmith AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = builder AddOpeningHours
craft = builder AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = carpet_layer AddOpeningHours
craft = carpet_layer AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = chimney_sweeper AddOpeningHours
craft = chimney_sweeper AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = cleaning AddOpeningHours
craft = cleaning AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = floorer AddOpeningHours
craft = floorer AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = gardener AddOpeningHours
craft = gardener AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = metal_construction AddOpeningHours
craft = metal_construction AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = painter AddOpeningHours
craft = painter AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = parquet_layer AddOpeningHours
craft = parquet_layer AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = plasterer AddOpeningHours
craft = plasterer AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

unreviewed ones (some of these are definitely not applicable, some are definitely applicable - not sure which for now)

craft = agricultural_engines AddOpeningHours
craft = agricultural_engines AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = basket_maker AddOpeningHours
craft = basket_maker AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = confectionery AddOpeningHours
craft = confectionery AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = glaziery AddOpeningHours
craft = glaziery AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = handicraft AddOpeningHours
craft = handicraft AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = hvac AddOpeningHours
craft = hvac AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = insulation AddOpeningHours
craft = insulation AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = joiner AddOpeningHours
craft = joiner AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = photographic_laboratory AddOpeningHours
craft = photographic_laboratory AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = plumber AddOpeningHours
craft = plumber AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = pottery AddOpeningHours
craft = pottery AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = rigger AddOpeningHours
craft = rigger AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = roofer AddOpeningHours
craft = roofer AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = saddler AddOpeningHours
craft = saddler AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = scaffolder AddOpeningHours
craft = scaffolder AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = sculptor AddOpeningHours
craft = sculptor AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = tiler AddOpeningHours
craft = tiler AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
craft = tinsmith AddOpeningHours
craft = tinsmith AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
healthcare = community_health_worker AddPlaceName
healthcare = community_health_worker AddOpeningHours
healthcare = community_health_worker AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
healthcare = midwife AddOpeningHours
office = advertising_agency AddOpeningHours
office = advertising_agency AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = architect AddOpeningHours
office = architect AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = construction_company AddOpeningHours
office = construction_company AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = consulting AddOpeningHours
office = consulting AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = courier AddOpeningHours
office = courier AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = engineer AddOpeningHours
office = engineer AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = financial AddOpeningHours
office = financial AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = foundation AddOpeningHours
office = foundation AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = graphic_design AddOpeningHours
office = graphic_design AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = guide AddOpeningHours
office = guide AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = logistics AddOpeningHours
office = logistics AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = moving_company AddOpeningHours
office = moving_company AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = physician AddOpeningHours
office = physician AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = political_party AddOpeningHours
office = private_investigator AddOpeningHours
office = private_investigator AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = security AddOpeningHours
office = security AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = surveyor AddOpeningHours
office = surveyor AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
office = translator AddOpeningHours
office = translator AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
leisure = dance AddOpeningHours
leisure = dance AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
leisure = fishing AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
leisure = horse_riding AddOpeningHours
leisure = horse_riding AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
leisure = hot_tub AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
leisure = resort AddPlaceName
leisure = resort AddOpeningHours
leisure = resort AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
leisure = sports_centre AddOpeningHours
leisure = swimming_pool AddOpeningHours
leisure = swimming_pool AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = arts_centre AddOpeningHours
amenity = baking_oven AddPlaceName
amenity = baking_oven AddOpeningHours
amenity = baking_oven AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = bicycle_rental AddPlaceName
amenity = bicycle_rental AddOpeningHours
amenity = bicycle_rental AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = bicycle_wash AddPlaceName
amenity = bicycle_wash AddOpeningHours
amenity = bicycle_wash AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = binoculars AddPlaceName
amenity = binoculars AddOpeningHours
amenity = binoculars AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = boat_rental AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = boat_storage AddPlaceName
amenity = boat_storage AddOpeningHours
amenity = boat_storage AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = bus_station AddPlaceName
amenity = bus_station AddOpeningHours
amenity = bus_station AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = car_pooling AddPlaceName
amenity = car_pooling AddOpeningHours
amenity = car_pooling AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = car_sharing AddPlaceName
amenity = car_sharing AddOpeningHours
amenity = car_sharing AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = charging_station AddPlaceName
amenity = charging_station AddOpeningHours
amenity = charging_station AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = driver_training AddPlaceName
amenity = driver_training AddOpeningHours
amenity = driver_training AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = exhibition_centre AddOpeningHours
amenity = exhibition_centre AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = ferry_terminal AddOpeningHours
amenity = give_box AddPlaceName
amenity = give_box AddOpeningHours
amenity = give_box AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = karaoke_box AddPlaceName
amenity = karaoke_box AddOpeningHours
amenity = karaoke_box AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = lavoir AddPlaceName
amenity = lavoir AddOpeningHours
amenity = lavoir AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = library_dropoff AddPlaceName
amenity = library_dropoff AddOpeningHours
amenity = library_dropoff AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = luggage_locker AddPlaceName
amenity = luggage_locker AddOpeningHours
amenity = luggage_locker AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = mortuary AddPlaceName
amenity = mortuary AddOpeningHours
amenity = mortuary AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = motorcycle_rental AddPlaceName
amenity = motorcycle_rental AddOpeningHours
amenity = motorcycle_rental AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = parcel_locker AddPlaceName
amenity = parcel_locker AddOpeningHours
amenity = parcel_locker AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = photo_booth AddPlaceName
amenity = photo_booth AddOpeningHours
amenity = photo_booth AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = post_depot AddPlaceName
amenity = post_depot AddOpeningHours
amenity = post_depot AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = ranger_station AddOpeningHours
amenity = refugee_site AddPlaceName
amenity = refugee_site AddOpeningHours
amenity = refugee_site AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = sanitary_dump_station AddPlaceName
amenity = sanitary_dump_station AddOpeningHours
amenity = sanitary_dump_station AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = shower AddPlaceName
amenity = shower AddOpeningHours
amenity = shower AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = social_centre AddOpeningHours
amenity = social_centre AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = stripclub AddOpeningHours
amenity = studio AddOpeningHours
amenity = studio AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = toilets AddOpeningHours
amenity = vacuum_cleaner AddPlaceName
amenity = vacuum_cleaner AddOpeningHours
amenity = vacuum_cleaner AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
amenity = waste_transfer_station AddPlaceName
amenity = waste_transfer_station AddOpeningHours
amenity = waste_transfer_station AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

[paulklie]

leisure = escape_game AddOpeningHours

In my experience these rarely have regular or signed opening hours since everything is appointment based. The rest (in the first section) looks good to me though.

[matkoniecz]

leisure = escape_game AddOpeningHours moved it to a separate section and will hide it

[paulklie]

I was also thinking of asking for highway=rest_area place name (33.8% usage). What do you think?

[matkoniecz]

I looked at https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/2e7M and quite a lot was already dubious/bad

I worry that many added would be also on a bad side

[paulklie]

Once openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema#1362 gets merged we could also ask for craft=atelier

[paulklie]

expect those to be by appointment, so opening hours should be likely not asked here:

We could maybe add places like these to #6492, as "only update if opening hours is already set".

leisure = bleachers AddPlaceName

I feel like people would just add the name of the stadium in many cases.

leisure = fishing AddPlaceName
leisure = fishing AddOpeningHours

Here in sweden these basically never have opening hours (maybe seasons) or names.

leisure = hot_tub AddPlaceName
leisure = hot_tub AddOpeningHours

Most of these seem to be individual hot tubs in swimming places. They seem to just have the same opening hours / name as the underlying place?

leisure = ice_rink AddPlaceName
leisure = ice_rink AddOpeningHours
leisure = ice_rink AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
leisure = indoor_play AddPlaceName
leisure = indoor_play AddOpeningHours
leisure = indoor_play AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

This sounds very good.

leisure = sports_hall AddOpeninHours

Most of these would be in schools, does not make sence to me.

leisure = swimming_area AddPlaceName
leisure = swimming_area AddOpeningHours
leisure = swimming_area AddWheelchairAccessBusiness
leisure = swimming_pool AddOpeningHours

I think this kind of information should be on the public bath / bathing place tag instead.

amenity = baking_oven AddOpeningHours

Tend to be open for events in my experience.

amenity = grave_yard AddPlaceName
amenity = grave_yard AddOpeningHours
amenity = grave_yard AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

This makes alot of sence to me.

amenity = hospital AddOpeningHours

Maybe spammy with alot of 24/7, but probably still very usefull.

amenity = kneipp_water_cure AddPlaceName
amenity = kneipp_water_cure AddOpeningHours
amenity = kneipp_water_cure AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

Might all be 24/4 but sounds good to me.

amenity = library_dropoff AddOpeningHours
amenity = luggage_locker AddOpeningHours
amenity = parcel_locker AddOpeningHours
amenity = refugee_site AddOpeningHours

Isn't the point of them that they are open 24/7?

amenity = parcel_locker AddPlaceName

amenity = polling_station AddPlaceName
amenity = polling_station AddOpeningHours
amenity = polling_station AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

Hard to survey out side of election season.

amenity = public_bath AddPlaceName
amenity = public_bath AddOpeningHours
amenity = public_bath AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

Sounds good to me.

amenity = recycling AddOpeningHours

Already the case for recycling center. Do bins need opening times? Maybe only for updating.

amenity = shower AddOpeningHours

Already done with fee=yes.

amenity = toilets AddOpeningHours

Already done with fee=yes

amenity = toilets AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

Has its own quest

[matkoniecz]

Thanks, reviewed list - dropped several, put ones you considered as viable to separate section on top.

amenity = library_dropoff AddOpeningHours
amenity = luggage_locker AddOpeningHours
amenity = parcel_locker AddOpeningHours

Isn't the point of them that they are open 24/7?

Some are not, for example some parcel lockers are indoor in malls/shops.

Maybe ask only for ones with opening hours, different than 24/7 and not edited for long time? (resurvey only)

Or only for indoor parcel lockers?

[matkoniecz]

looked at actual data of kneipp_water_cure and just dropped it

[matkoniecz]

after looking at data and thinking a bit: dropped also

leisure = ice_rink AddPlaceName
leisure = ice_rink AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

remaining ones in top section feel OK to add, but I am not feeling familiar enough with them to add them. Maybe I will look more at data or ask mappers?

[HolgerJeromin]

healthcare = rehabilitation AddOpeningHours

Could be hotel-like or a place to visit for a few hours.
needs appointments (with healthcare person).
Not like hospital or doctor where you walk in.

leisure = dance AddOpeningHours
leisure = horse_riding AddOpeningHours

Needs a trainer/lesson. So the quest should not be asked.

leisure = dance AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

Yes please

leisure = horse_riding AddWheelchairAccessBusiness

Nearly always =no in my experience.