Replace Gaufrette since it's deprecated

[jordisala1991]

Feature Request

I have been looking at gauffrete and I don't know if it is still maintained or we should move away from it.

There are other very popular alternatives like: https://github.com/thephpleague/flysystem

IMHO looking at the future. The best would be to not take care for the FileSystem. I mean, if we are integrating with 3rd party bundle/package we should provide only the default filesystem integration and provide a way to configure an alternative filesystem service. This service can be configured with the 3rd party tool.

This way we don't end up having to replicate every single option of the different adapters, like: #1817

This is probably something to tackle for 5.0, since we don't have many resources to do it here, and there are other importants things to do.

WDYT @sonata-project/contributors . Do you know a better alternative to gauffrete? Do you use it for your own projects?

[VincentLanglet]

WDYT @sonata-project/contributors . Do you know a better alternative to gauffrete? Do you use it for your own projects?

I'm using gauffrete in my project, but we recently started to use https://github.com/thephpleague/flysystem too and we plan to remove gauffrete.

[VincentLanglet]

WDYT @sonata-project/contributors . Do you know a better alternative to gauffrete? Do you use it for your own projects?

I'm using gauffrete in my project, but we recently started to use https://github.com/thephpleague/flysystem too and we plan to remove gauffrete.

We got stuck because of an issue between VichUploader and Symfony constraints.
dustin10/VichUploaderBundle#1217

Dunno if it can be an issue here too

[mvhirsch]

@VincentLanglet is dustin10/VichUploaderBundle#1217 still relevant with flysystem v3 and for SonataMediaBundle?

Btw. title should be:

-Gauffrete
+Gaufrette

😇

[VincentLanglet]

I don't use anymore VichUploader for my work ; so I don't know.

I also never used SonataMediaBundle, and don't use SOnataAdminBundle anymore.
I'm just low-maintaining them as an act of kindness

[OskarStark]

Title adjusted

[mvhirsch]

Since Gaufrette didn't released new versions since Nov. 2022 and lacks active contributions on main branch; I guess SonataMediaBundle should be refactored using Flysystem.

I'd like to provide a PR that's using Flystem (v3) but I could use some help from maintainers. I think this can't be done without breaking BC; but at least in a simple upgrade-path for users still using SonataMediaBundle. WDYT?

[VincentLanglet]

without breaking BC

Either we find a way to drop gaufrete in a BC way like a config option "lib: gaufrete/flysystem" if possible/needed.

Or we introduce the BC break on 5.x ?