Skip to content

Ill-typed VC #4045

@mtzguido

Description

@mtzguido
open FStar.Exn

exception DivZero

let test0 (#a:Type u#0) () : Exn a (requires True) (ensures fun (r : result a) -> r == E DivZero) =
  FStar.Exn.raise DivZero;
  ()

let test1 (#a:Type u#1) () : Exn a (requires True) (ensures fun (r : result a) -> r == E DivZero) =
  FStar.Exn.raise DivZero;
  ()

The second function fails. Turning on enough debugging shows:

Encoding query formula {: forall (a: Type u#1)
  (_: Prims.unit)
  (p: FStar.Pervasives.ex_post u#1 a)
  (_:
  _:
  Prims.unit
    { forall (r: FStar.Pervasives.result u#1 a).
        Prims.eq2 u#1
          #(FStar.Pervasives.result u#1 a)
          r
          (FStar.Pervasives.E u#1 #a Clase08.Eff.DivZero) ==>
        p r })
  (r: FStar.Pervasives.result u#0 Prims.unit)
  (_:
  _:
  Prims.unit
    { Prims.eq2 u#0
        #(FStar.Pervasives.result u#0 Prims.unit)
        r
        (FStar.Pervasives.E u#0 #Prims.unit Clase08.Eff.DivZero) })
  (_:
  _:
  Prims.unit
    { ~(exists (ra1: Prims.unit).
          Prims.eq2 u#0
            #(FStar.Pervasives.result u#0 Prims.unit)
            r
            (FStar.Pervasives.V u#0 #Prims.unit ra1)) })
  (e: Prims.exn)
  (_:
  _:
  Prims.unit
    { Prims.eq2 u#0
        #(FStar.Pervasives.result u#0 Prims.unit)
        r
        (FStar.Pervasives.E u#0 #Prims.unit e) }).
  Prims.auto_squash u#0 (p (FStar.Pervasives.E u#0 #a e))  // !!!!!!
} Done encoding
Z3 says: unknown
Z3 says: unknown
Z3 says: unknown
Z3 says: unknown
* Error 19 at Clase08.Eff.fst(12,2-13,4):
  - Assertion failed
  - The SMT solver could not prove the query. Use --query_stats for more
    details.
  - See also /home/guido/r/fstar/pristine/stage2/out/lib/fstar/ulib/FStar.Pervasives.fsti(403,19-403,31)

Note the ill-typed application of p in the goal: the u#0 should be u#1.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions